It didn't matter, though, as we had plenty of work to do indoors. I went over John Carlson's observations on value in the landscape, and I reiterated the importance of minimizing value shifts within masses. To illustrate, I painted a demonstration based on a photo of El Morro National Monument in New Mexico.
Here's the value sketch I made. You'll note that I used only three values: dark, light and a mid-value. Carlson writes about breaking up the landscape into four values. But because the hard pastels I use for underpainting don't have an extensive value range, it's sometimes difficult to find four pastels with enough separation in value to indicate clearly that masses are of different values. Three values work fine, just so long as you later expand the range with softer pastels, which typically have lighter lights and darker darks.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4fb7c/4fb7ced19cddb790c8169f4a70311faa3872320d" alt=""
Here's the complete "working palette" of pastels that I used for the painting. Rather than put the pastels back into their proper spots in the box after using them, I placed them in a small plastic lid so I could find them again quickly if needed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/95e0b/95e0b6742b6ddce9c4315a5c181756dc1fd3192a" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/34e22/34e22661468947a5411d66c58199f790dafb6ede" alt=""
Finally, here's the finished piece. As you can see, I gradually worked in a few more values to expand the range. Still, the design remained strong, thanks to the practice of minimizing shifts in value within the masses.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d7862/d78622b2a8c8392de42c29e989975fb09beea67a" alt=""
On Wednesday, we'll dive head-first into expressive color. In the evening, I have a book signing at the Springfield Art Association, where I'll be reading from Through a Painter's Brush and the upcoming book, Backpacker Painting.